This week is the mid-point for Part 2, Ellsworth Toohey. Up until this week, we really didn’t learn that much about him. He seems to show up quite frequently and also has an unwarranted amount of influence without any sort of credentials or reason. At least this week we get a peak at Toohey the character. For some reason, when I was reading the back story, the image of a vindictive Young Sheldon came to mind. Not that I have watch that show but have seen it in passing.

First, we have the prerequisite reading summary for the week. Now that Dominique recognizes her inferiority to Roark, she is going to punish him so that his moral superiority is not recognized. She goes about it by driving business to Keating, seemingly the only thing that Roark cares about that. This behavior finds a kindred ally with Toohey who feels the same way about Roark even though Toohey is much more masked about his feelings.
Despite Dominique’s efforts, Roark is gaining some success. Roark goes after Mallory (the sculptor) to try and revive him and work on a sculpture for the commission. Roark’s argument is that only personal joy leads to independence. Mallory agrees and the building is completed but of course the efforts of Toohey and Dominique submarine the opening. Roark is sued for the damages to convert the temple into a children’s home. Roark puts up no defense.
To me, the heart of the this week’s reading is the backstory of Ellsworth Toohey. It would seem that he grew up as sort of a know-it-all wimp. Because of that he was bullied until he realized that he could outsmart his enemies. He would use the art of surprise and strike in the case of his hose attack on the bullies new suit. They seemed to back off of him because they realized that they could not compete.
It is the kind of troupe that is old as time from a horror story standpoint. I recently saw a trailer for the movie “Carrie”. This is one that I haven’t read or seen the movie, but I understand the story to be a girl is bullied and she ends up dead. Consequently, her ghost comes back to haunt the people that were the bullies. This is Toohey. And the sad part is that he can even recognize right and wrong, good and bad and yet he still chooses to bully in his column.
Quite possibly the reason has to do with Toohey’s belief in Socialism. It is all kind of complicated, but his being bullied has lead him to the belief that he is underserved or underrecognized. As a result, he is going to take from his aggressors. Once status quo is achieved, socialism requires personal or community sacrifice for the common good.
I think that we all have a little Robin Hood in all of us. The story is part of our social fabric. It is about leveling the playing field when some other individual(s) have all the power. To a point, I agree. It is equivalent to believing that I cannot become a timber baron because the US government stole all of the land and divided it up in the 1860s Homestead act. So, now we have the giant corporations like Louisiana Pacific and Weyerhaeuser that own all the land that is not BLM and Forest Service. If you do not pay for an annual lease, you are trespassing on Weyerhaeuser land.
So this was land that was stolen from the indigenous tribes, distributed amongst the already wealthy and today we are prohibited from access and use. There is only one lease per unit and typically the process is very competitive. As a person, I believe in private property. So let’s say the companies purchased the land at some point. It still doesn’t change the fact that it is a very selective access process.
But, let’s not cry in our Cheerios, what’s done is done. I saw an article after the election that stated “If so many Americans despise Socialism, whey are they electing candidates that proclaim to be Socialists?”. The answer is that they do not despise Socialism. They do not like the label Socialist. The rest they love as long as they are not seeing direct consequences.
One year, my family volunteered at the Oregon State Fair. Our job was to hand out tickets to Veterans for a free bowl of chowder lunch. This was probably an ill begotten effort because the tickets were supposed to go Veterans only. However, the number of people that demanded six tickets for their whole family was high. I get the point, nobody wants to go to the fair with their family and then go off alone to some event that they don’t know. The fact remains that when they got something for free, they wanted as much of it as we were willing to give. So much so that their selfishness took away from Veterans coming in the door after them. We ran out of tickets in about 90 minutes.
The other group that stands out in my memory were the ones that refused the tickets. They frequently said “proud to serve”. You see these are both socialists. The ones that sacrifice for the common good as well as the ones that take because they can. If Americans were not socialist, they wouldn’t have Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security, WIC, Section 8 housing, welfare, National Parks, state parks, libraries and all the other things. Just don’t call us Socialist.
End Your Programming Routine: When I was thinking about this topic, I was wondering what life would be like without all of these entitlement programs. How would I think about retirement differently if there was no such concept of Social Security? I would have to provide for myself in some fashion until I died. It might make different life choices for a career. Rather than working a job, I would need to have some sort of residual income or at the very least have a career that I perform at 80 (that is if I didn’t die at 40). I think what many of us want is not sharing the results of our labor, but some sort of say in how it goes. The election was not a mandate for more partisan socialism but a rejection of how it is going.





Recent Comments